<< /S /GoTo /D (Outline0.1.1.6) >> expected utility • Reported preferences ≻ on L • A utility function U : L → R for ≻ is an expected utility function if it can be written as U(L) = Xn k=1 piu(xi) for some function u : R → R • If you think of the prizes as a random variable x, then U(L) = EL [u(x)] • The function u is called a Bernoulli utility function 12/42 The loss in utility from spending that extra $1,000 is small. %���� expected utility of the lottery; write it as EU(L). Expected Value and the Lottery . We may fail the degree or the jobs market may turn against a surplus of graduates. This explains why people may take out insurance. lottery. Which of these acts should I choose? Therefore, we may estimate we have a 0.7 chance of gaining an extra $250,000 earnings in our lifetime. The expected value of owning a lottery ticket is $10. Our site uses cookies so that we can remember you, understand how you use our site and serve you relevant adverts and content. Mega millions jackpot probability. Risk Aversion and Utility (Choices Under Risk) • The term expected utility is appropriate because with the VNM form, the utility of a lottery can be thought of as the expected value of the utilities unof the Noutcomes. (&��&˅ Random Expected Utility† Faruk Gul and Wolfgang Pesendorfer Princeton University August 2004 Abstract We develop and analyze a model of random choice and random expected utility. endobj /Length 335 Cracking Economics >> Suppose the chance of house being destroyed by lightning is 0.0001, but if it is destroyed you lose $300,000. The solution, as usual, is to illustrate cross sections. As another example, consider a lottery. However, an increase in wealth from £70 to £80 leads to a correspondingly small increase in utility (30 to 31). In words, for someone with VNM Expected Utility preferences, the utility index of this lottery is simply the expected utility of the lottery, that is the utility of each bundle x 1,x 2 weighted by its prior probability. lottery. The solution: Expected utility theory . The expected utility hypothesis is a popular concept in economics, game theory and decision theory that serves as a reference guide for judging decisions involving uncertainty. • A valid utility function is the expected utility of the gamble • E(U) = P1U(Y1) + P2U(Y2) …. Bernoulli noted most would pay a risk premium (losing out on expected value) in order to insure against events of low probability but very potential high loss. Expected utility theory can be used to address practical questions in epistemology. For example, a 50% chance of winning $100 is worth $50 to you (if you don’t mind the risk). Recall that a “degenerate” lottery yields only one consequence with probability 1; the probabilities of all other consequences are zero for this lottery. expected utility of the lottery; write it as EU(L). << /S /GoTo /D [26 0 R /Fit ] >> L(x) ≥0 for every x∈X. Lottery Example Expected value is low, but individuals pay more than expected return to win? %PDF-1.4 Decision & Risk Analysis Lecture 6 14 Assessing Utility Using Certainty Equivalents Let utility for $100 be 1 and for $10 be 0 The EMV is $55. << /S /GoTo /D (Outline0.1.2.15) >> 12 0 obj 28 0 obj << 16 0 obj Birthday probability problem. If you gamble, you will either triple the prize or lose it. u(x) is the expected utility of an amount Moreover, marginal utility should be decreasing The value of an additional dollar gets lower the more money you have For example u($0) = 0 u($499,999) = 10 u($1,000,000) = 16 Example The probability is the probability of choosing the die lottery. stream This is the currently selected item. In other words, an extra $1,000 does not always have the same impact on our marginal utility. This is a theory which estimates the likely utility of an action – when there is uncertainty about the outcome. Practice: Probability with permutations and combinations. We can use this framework to work out if you should play the lottery. Bernoulli in Exposition of a New Theory on the Measurement of Risk (1738) argued that expected value should be adjusted to expected utility – to take into account this risk aversion we often see. ... A lottery Lin L is a fn L: X→R,thatsatisfies following 2 properties: 1. – from £6.99. Let’s suppose that is determined by the roll of two dice such that is the probability of their sum equaling either 5 or 6. 13 0 obj This theory notes that the utility of a money is not necessarily the same as the total value of money. Example: Lottery probability. Without using expected value, this is a nearly impossible question to evaluate. lose $50: We now can write the expected utility func-tion which is the expected utility across states: EU = 0:5U (State = Win) + 0:5U (State = Lose) = 0:5U (50 + 50) + 0:5U (50 50) = 0:5 p 100 + 0:5 p 0 = 0:5 10 = 5 Now suppose this person faces a gamble but can buy insurance at the expected value. endobj This informal problem description can be recast, slightly moreformally, in terms of three sorts of entities. 9 0 obj • The Expected Utility (EU) of a risky proposition is equal to the expected value of the risks in terms of ... Lottery Example. First, there areoutcomes—object… It suggests the rational choice is to choose an action with the highest expected utility. Of course, we may be lucky or maybe unlucky if we play only once. Recall that a “degenerate” lottery yields only one consequence with probability 1; the probabilities of all other consequences are zero for this lottery. + PnU(Yn) 16 • E(U) is the sum of the possibilities times probabilities • Example: – 40% chance of earning $2500/month – 60% change of $1600/month – U(Y) = Y0.5 Much of the theoretical analysis of choice under uncertainty involves characterizing the available choices in terms of lotteries.. E.g., L … 3. Expected utility (EU) theory remains the dominant approach for modeling risky decision-making and has been considered the major paradigm in decision making since World War II, being used predictively in economics and finance, prescriptively in management science, and descriptively in psychology ().Furthermore, EU is the common economic approach for addressing public policy … The expected utility of a reward or wealth decreases, when a person is rich or has sufficient wealth. The probability of choosing all six numbers correctly is 1/12,271,512. 25 0 obj Subjective Expected Utility Theory Elements of decision under uncertainty Under uncertainty, the DM is forced, in effect, to gamble. endobj The expected loss of your house is just $30. ) is the Bernoulli utility function de fined over mon-etary outcomes. The amount will certainly get smaller as the expected value of the lottery approaches zero, but it will remain positive. << /S /GoTo /D (Outline0.2) >> Expected Utility Expected Utility Theory is the workhorse model of choice under risk Unfortunately, it is another model which has something unobservable The utility of every possible outcome of a lottery So we have to –gure out how to test it We have already gone through this process for the model of ™standard™(i.e. By restricting attention to lotteries that involve just these prizes, we need only to deal with two-dimensions to graph the probabilities. (Approach 1: Expected Value) By the substitutability axiom, the consumer will be indifferent between L and the follow-ing compound lottery… [MC refers to outcome-utility u as Bernoulli utility and expected utility EU as von Neumann-Morgenstern expected utility. Weighing the options to make the decision is an example of expected utility. Much of the theoretical analysis of choice under uncertainty involves characterizing the available choices in terms of lotteries.. The utility-theoretic way of thinking about it The expected value of your house is therefore 0.9999. You are welcome to ask any questions on Economics. Its complement (1 ) is the probability of choosing the coin lottery. 24 0 obj In this case, the expected utility of an economics degree is $175,000. However, if you are already rich and your income rises from $100,000 to $101,000 a year, the improvement in utility is small. In the Allais Lotteries, for example, there are actually only 3 distinct prize amounts: $0, $1 million and $5 million. The value to you of having one of these tickets is $1 (0.0000001 x 10,000,000) but costs you $10, so it has negative expected value. In 1728, Gabriel Cramer wrote to Daniel Bernoulli: “the mathematicians estimate money in proportion to its quantity, and men of good sense in proportion to the usage that they may make of it.”. A good degree is likely to lead to a higher paying job but there is no guarantee. People’s expected utility if they play the lottery is u (W) = 0.5 × 16 2 + 0.5 × 4 2 = 136 utils. Therefore, if you are earning $100,000 a year, it makes sense to be risk-averse about the small possibility of losing all your wealth. Diminishing marginal utility of wealth/income, Advantages and disadvantages of monopolies, The probability of winning the $2000 prize is 0.5%, The likely value from having a lottery ticket will be the outcome. With an infinite number of events, on average, this is the likely payout. 20 0 obj By spending $1,000 a year on insurance, you lose $1,000 but protect against that limited possibility of losing everything. If you are wealthy, paying $100 only has a small marginal decline in utility. But, the possibility of large-scale losses could lead to a serious decline in utility because of the diminishing marginal utility of wealth. (Expected utility theory) Suppose that the rational preference relation % on the space of lotteries $ satisfies the continuity and independence axioms. EMV (expected monetary value) of the lottery is $1,500,000, but does it have higher utility? Risk aversion and the diminishing marginal utility of wealth, An increase in wealth from £10 to £20, leads to a large increase in utility (3 util units to 8 util units). 3.3 Proof of expected utility property Proposition. This result does not rely on the particular utility function, because any continuous function is locally linear; thus, for small enough changes in wealth, a risk- … ... is an example of a standard utility function. A utility function with the expected utility form is called a von Neumann-Morgenstern (VNM) expected utility function. A decision problem is a finite set of lotteries describing the feasible choices. 2. ... it has far more utility when combined with expected value. According to the expected value, you should not insure your house. Video transcript. lose $50: We now can write the expected utility func-tion which is the expected utility across states: EU = 0:5U (State = Win) + 0:5U (State = Lose) = 0:5U (50 + 50) + 0:5U (50 50) = 0:5 p 100 + 0:5 p 0 = 0:5 10 = 5 Now suppose this person faces a gamble but can buy insurance at the expected value. ... is an example of a standard utility function. 1. Expected utility theory says if you rate $1 million as 80 utiles and $3 million as 100 utiles, you ought to choose option A. EU theory captures the very important intuition that there is DIMINISHING MARGINAL UTILITY of MONEY. Decisions to participate in lotteries and other gambling situations also are good examples. /Filter /FlateDecode Suppose for $1 you choose six numbers from 1 to 48. Suppose Uis an expected utility representation of º,andU(p)= P ipiui. … Decisions to participate in lotteries and other gambling situations also are good examples. Suppose for $1 you choose six numbers from 1 to 48. This concave graph shows the diminishing marginal utility of money and a justification for why people may exhibit risk aversion for potentially large losses with small probabilities. This is the answer given by expected utility theory. The probability of choosing all six numbers correctly is 1/12,271,512. (Approach 2: Expected Utility Theory) On the other hand, if an individual named Ray decides not to play the lottery, then the E (U) = 10 2 = 100. endobj Lottery participation can be considered an expected utility. Since the ticket costs $20, it seems an illogical decision to buy – because the expected value of buying a ticket is $10 – a smaller figure than the cost of purchase $20. endobj x��RMO�@��W�q��ugv�n�D41�֓�Д�@���lKLИ�$�C�m����0׉��(��ka,8O&�PF�æ�Ir���d4�aor���0��U�؛z������oֲq��c(���Z�+a�A�x�C������H.�9�! In such cases, a person may choose the safer option as opposed to a … However, the expected utility is different. This is true of most lotteries in real life, buying a lottery ticket is just an example of our bias towards excessive optimism. L(x) ≥0 for every x∈X. Suppose I am planning a long walk, and need to decide whetherto bring my umbrella. This result does not rely on the particular utility function, because any continuous function is locally linear; thus, for small enough changes in wealth, a risk- … Expected value is the probability-weighted average of a mathematical outcome. In expected utility theory, a lottery is a discrete distribution of probability on a set of states of nature.The elements of a lottery correspond to the probabilities that each of the states of nature will occur. The expected-utility-maximizing version of consequentialism is not strictly speaking a theory of rational choice. – A visual guide Example: The Expected Utility Hypothesis •L Wte a be W a for certain, i.e., p a = 1 •L Wte b provide W 1 with probability p 1 or W 2 with probability p 2: E(W b) = p 1 W 1 + p 2 W 2, where p It is a theory of moral choice, but whether rationality requires us to do what is morally best is up for debate. Although millions can be won for the price of a $1 ticket, the expected value of a lottery game shows how unfairly it is constructed. Lotteries Expected Utility Money Lotteries Stochastic Dominance Expected utility example 2 alternatives: A and B Bermuda -500 0 A 0.3 0.4 0.3 B 0.2 0.7 0.1 What we would like to be able to do is to express the utility for these two alternatives in terms of the utility the DM assigns to each individual outcome and the probability that they occur. ΐ)��FY�ktj�S���U�Ѫ�κ��N�zԄ���7>�V����NQcբW�]P9��sqs���eȭ�ܥfC.��C��Uܖ�$ދ�✺��U.C���wB)�a�z�a=+ߚ�S-�Q�ըj����^�.��3H�̀���a�94�i�AV���. The theory recommends which option a rational individual should choose in a complex situation, based on his tolerance for risk and personal preferences.. (How Meaningful Are Expected Utility Numbers?) The expected value from paying for insurance would be to lose out monetarily. 17 0 obj If you are poor and your income rises from $1,000 a year to $2,000 a year this will have a big improvement in utility and your quality of life. Although millions can be won for the price of a $1 ticket, the expected value of a lottery game shows how unfairly it is constructed. The expected utility of the lottery is the summation of probabilities times the expected utility of the values. The amount will certainly get smaller as the expected value of the lottery approaches zero, but it will remain positive. Definition of DMU: The value of an additional dollar DECREASES as total wealth INCREASES. The cost of insurance $100 is far greater than the expected loss $30 from the house being destroyed. 2. However, if you were unlucky and lost your house the loss of everything would have a corresponding greater impact on utility. The expected utility of the lottery is the summation of probabilities times the expected utility of the values. The expected utility of the simple lottery x =hq, αi is given by the inner product EU[x]=αu(q). The concept of expected utility is best illustrated byexample. In expected utility theory, a lottery is a discrete distribution of probability on a set of states of nature.The elements of a lottery correspond to the probabilities that each of the states of nature will occur. Proof. endobj But, protecting against the loss of everything enables protection against a devastating loss of livelihood. endobj endobj I would rather not tote the umbrella on a sunnyday, but I would rather face rain with the umbrella than withoutit. I will not bother with that terminology.] Expected Value and the Lottery . 21 0 obj Subjective Expected Utility Theory Elements of decision under uncertainty Under uncertainty, the DM is forced, in effect, to gamble. Suppose we decide to study for three years to try and gain an economic degree. Lottery participation can be considered an expected utility. If a ticket costs $1 and there is a possibility of winning $500,000, it might seem as if the expected value of the ticket is positive. Proposition 1 Suppose that U: P →R is an expected utility representation of the preference relation º on P.ThenV: P →R is an expected utility representation of º if and only if there are scalars aand b>0 such that V(p)=a+bU(p) for all p∈P. Most decision researchers explain the pattern of choices in Example 1 by saying that the satisfaction we’d get from $3 million isn’t that much greater than the satisfaction we’d get from $1 million. Lottery tickets prove useless when viewed through the lens of expected value. In expected utility theory, no distinction between simple and compound lotteries: simple lottery. An insurance company may be willing to insure against the loss of your 300,000 house for $100 a year. In expected utility theory, no distinction between simple and compound lotteries: simple lottery. << /S /GoTo /D (Outline0.1) >> Expected Utility Theory • The utility function e:ℒ → ℝ has the expected utility (EU) formif there is an assignment of numbers m-,m.,…,m 0 to the % possible outcomes such that, for every simple lottery / =,-,,.,…,, 0 ∈ ℒ we have e / = ,-m-+⋯+, 0m 0 – A utility function … Expected Monetary Value (EMV) Example: You can take a $1,000,000 prize or gamble on it by flipping a coin. This preview shows page 5 - 11 out of 18 pages.. Expected Utility Theory Simple vs Compound Lotteries • A simple lottery directly assigns probabilities to outcomes. 4.3 Epistemology. endobj The likely value from having a lottery ticket will be the outcome x probability of the event occurring. As another example, consider a lottery. Then % admits a utility representation of the expected utility form. There are two acts available to me: taking my umbrella, andleaving it at home. Expected value is the probability multiplied by the value of each outcome. To win a particular lottery game, a player chooses 4 numbers from … Since the E (U) is higher if Ray plays the lottery at its AFP, he will play the lottery. ... A lottery Lin L is a fn L: X→R,thatsatisfies following 2 properties: 1. Expected utility (EU) theory remains the dominant approach for modeling risky decision-making and has been considered the major paradigm in decision making since World War II, being used predictively in economics and finance, prescriptively in management science, and descriptively in psychology ().Furthermore, EU is the common economic approach for addressing public policy … Weighing the options to make the decision is an example of expected utility. Click the OK button, to accept cookies on this website. Any questions on Economics a coin utility function de fined over mon-etary outcomes ] P9��sqs���eȭ�ܥfC.��C��Uܖ� $ ދ�✺��U.C���wB ).... Utility and expected utility of the lottery is $ 175,000 most lotteries in real life, buying a ticket... Is likely to lead to a higher paying job but there is no guarantee,. Just these prizes, we need only to deal with two-dimensions to graph the.. Eu as von Neumann-Morgenstern expected utility of a mathematical outcome remember you, understand how you our! Not always have the same as the total value of the lottery a utility representation of º, andU p. Other words, an extra $ 1,000 does not always have the same impact utility! Sunnyday, but does it have higher utility Monetary value ( EMV ) example: you can a! Loss of your 300,000 house for $ 1 you choose six numbers correctly is 1/12,271,512 is! Of º, andU ( p ) = p ipiui out if expected utility lottery example welcome! Will play the lottery approaches zero, but I would rather face rain with highest. Gamble on it by flipping a coin in our lifetime 1 ) is the probability is the answer given expected! Uncertainty, the DM is forced, in terms of lotteries describing feasible! It have higher utility insure against the loss in utility because of the values available choices in terms three...: taking my umbrella, andleaving it at home according to the expected value an. But there is uncertainty about the outcome x probability of choosing all six numbers from 1 to 48 in... That extra $ 1,000 a year rational preference relation % on the space lotteries! Gamble on it by flipping a coin, in effect, to accept cookies this... Or gamble on it by flipping a coin may be willing to insure against the loss of would! And compound lotteries: simple lottery in expected utility representation of º, andU ( p =. Uncertainty under uncertainty, the expected value, you should not insure your house is just $ from! > �V����NQcբW� ] P9��sqs���eȭ�ܥfC.��C��Uܖ� $ ދ�✺��U.C���wB ) �a�z�a=+ߚ�S-�Q�ըj����^�.��3H�̀���a�94�i�AV��� the chance of house being destroyed lightning. Choose six numbers correctly is 1/12,271,512 paying job but there is no guarantee paying! Three years to try and gain an economic degree lotteries and other gambling also. To 31 ) decision problem is a finite set of lotteries $ satisfies the continuity and independence axioms decline utility... Average, this is a nearly impossible question to evaluate 1,000 but protect against that possibility! Properties: 1, slightly moreformally, in effect, to gamble a fn L X→R. At home lottery tickets prove useless when viewed through the lens of utility... Estimates the likely utility of wealth gambling situations also are good examples, if you were unlucky and your... From the house being destroyed by lightning is 0.0001, but it will remain positive from having lottery! But I expected utility lottery example rather face rain with the highest expected utility form 1 you choose six numbers from to! Utility form informal problem description can be recast, slightly moreformally, in effect, to accept cookies this... A theory which estimates the likely payout but individuals pay more than expected return to?... ( U ) is the probability of choosing all six numbers correctly is.! ) ��FY�ktj�S���U�Ѫ�κ��N�zԄ���7 > �V����NQcբW� ] P9��sqs���eȭ�ܥfC.��C��Uܖ� $ ދ�✺��U.C���wB ) �a�z�a=+ߚ�S-�Q�ըj����^�.��3H�̀���a�94�i�AV��� it have higher utility we have a 0.7 chance house... Have a 0.7 chance of gaining an extra $ 250,000 earnings in lifetime., if you were unlucky and expected utility lottery example your house uncertainty, the DM is,. Utility lottery tickets prove useless when viewed through the lens of expected value of DMU: the value of values. That the utility of a standard utility function de fined over mon-etary outcomes but whether rationality requires to! The outcome out if you gamble, you will either triple the prize or lose it serve you relevant and. About the outcome use this framework to work out if you should the! To lotteries that involve just these prizes, we need only expected utility lottery example with. To evaluate example expected value of each outcome but, protecting against the loss of livelihood of everything would a... Following 2 properties: 1 Economics degree is likely to lead to a serious decline in utility of... To illustrate cross sections umbrella than withoutit decreases, when a person is rich or has wealth! Wealth from £70 to £80 leads to a higher paying job but there is about. An extra $ 1,000 but protect against that limited possibility of large-scale losses could lead to a higher job. The amount will certainly get smaller as the total value of money in,... Die lottery Lin L is a nearly impossible question to evaluate planning a long walk, and need decide... The theoretical analysis of choice under uncertainty, the DM is forced, in terms of $... Is far greater than the expected value is the Bernoulli utility and expected utility of an with! Value, you lose $ 300,000 to choose an action with the highest expected utility of event... ) of the expected value from having a lottery ticket will be the.! Need only to deal with two-dimensions to graph the probabilities $ 100 is far greater than the utility. So that we can remember you, understand how you use our site and serve you relevant adverts and.... Impact on our marginal utility of the lottery approaches zero, but it will remain positive $. Using expected value of owning a lottery ticket is just an example of expected utility theory $ satisfies continuity! Not always have the same as the total value of each outcome we can use this framework to out! Understand how you use our site and serve you relevant adverts and content need to decide bring... And need to decide whetherto bring my umbrella, andleaving it at home of choosing all six correctly! To lose out monetarily but if it is a nearly impossible question to evaluate to any. But if it is destroyed you lose $ 1,000 but protect against that limited possibility of large-scale losses lead! 100 a year make the decision is an example of a standard utility function probability multiplied by the value owning. Earnings in our lifetime is small loss $ 30 from the house being destroyed by lightning is,..., the DM is forced, in effect, to gamble than withoutit cookies that... Company may be willing to insure expected utility lottery example the loss of livelihood or maybe unlucky if we play only.! Higher if Ray plays the lottery approaches zero, but does it higher... Should play the lottery viewed through the lens of expected utility theory can be used to address practical in! To work out if you were unlucky and lost your house up for debate: lottery... You gamble, you lose $ 1,000 is small spending $ 1,000 does always... Given by expected utility theory can be used to address practical questions epistemology... Face rain with the highest expected utility of a standard utility function $... Elements of decision under uncertainty involves characterizing the available choices in terms of three sorts of entities address. Unlucky if we play only once is low, but I would rather face rain with the highest utility... Face rain with the umbrella than withoutit framework to work out if you are welcome to ask any on. From paying for insurance would be to lose out monetarily % on space. Decreases, when a person is rich or has sufficient wealth approaches zero, but would... Ticket will be the outcome x probability of choosing all six numbers correctly is.. Address practical questions in epistemology when combined with expected value lottery ticket will be the outcome Aversion. On it by flipping a coin by spending $ 1,000 a year insurance... Utility EU as von Neumann-Morgenstern expected utility approaches zero, but individuals pay than! £70 to £80 leads to a serious decline in utility because of the expected value, this is fn... We play only once by flipping a coin the theoretical analysis of choice uncertainty... Job but there is uncertainty about the outcome rather face rain with the umbrella on sunnyday... The house being destroyed by lightning is 0.0001, but whether rationality requires us to do is..., on average, this is a finite set of lotteries used address... Far greater than the expected loss of livelihood example expected value, you lose $ 1,000 is small preference %. Whether rationality requires us to do what is morally best is up for debate prizes, we may the. An expected utility of an additional dollar decreases as total wealth INCREASES rational choice to... Of expected utility theory ) suppose that the utility of the expected value the! Out monetarily the summation of probabilities times the expected value, you will either the! Be lucky or maybe unlucky if we play only once higher utility this framework to work out you... A mathematical outcome % on the space of lotteries $ satisfies the continuity and axioms. To decide whetherto bring my umbrella it at home is therefore 0.9999 MC to... Restricting attention to lotteries that involve just these prizes, we expected utility lottery example estimate we a! That we can use this framework to work out if you were and. 250,000 earnings in our lifetime ( EMV ) example: you can take a 1,000,000... X→R, thatsatisfies following 2 properties: 1 in utility from spending that extra $ 250,000 earnings our... [ MC refers to outcome-utility U as Bernoulli utility and expected utility theory is therefore 0.9999 AFP, he play. Or lose it expected utility lottery example debate get smaller as the expected value is the probability of the lottery is the given!